Costco doesn’t kid around when it comes to quality. Sure, the prices can’t be beat, but don’t let the affordability fool you—the warehouse chain doesn’t slack on quality control. Still, don’t take our word for it. Many consumers check reviews before making a purchase, which makes a lot of sense. Why spend your hard-earned money on something that others regret buying? We scoured Costco’s inventory for the absolute top-rated grocery products that exceed expectations. To save you from buyer’s remorse, here are a few Costco items that each have 2,000 or more 5-star reviews.

Kirkland Signature Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Vegetable oils are rich in healthy fats, but none are as esteemed as olive oil. Costco’s private label, Kirkland Signature, makes a few different olive oils to choose from, but this one is organic, extra-virgin, kosher, and cold pressed. It basically checks a lot of boxes for a lot of customers, which is probably why it has nearly 5,000 perfect ratings. “I use a lot of olive oil, and find this particular product indispensable,” shared one reviewer on Costco.com. Use it in your cooking, or drizzle it atop salads, soups, and pastas.

Peet’s Coffee Decaf House Blend K-Cup Pods

Whether you use whole beans, grounds, pods, or capsules, Costco has a wide selection of coffee products. But one is more revered than the rest, and it may surprise you: These decaf pods have upwards of 7,500 5-star reviews. The contents of each pod is darkly roasted to yield a stronger flavor, and decaffeinated using a water process, which is considered the gold standard for decaf coffee. “This bold house blend decaf is perfect for those that love the flavor without the caffeine, or for that second morning cup without the jitters,” wrote one happy customer. “It is a dark, delicious, bold coffee,” noted another. “I would never suspect it to be decaffeinated.”

Kirkland Signature Chicken Breast

They say that canned goods are cheaper than fresh foods, but saving money isn’t the only reason to stock your pantry with Costco’s canned chicken breast—it’s also convenient. Pile a serving onto salads or sandwiches for a quick source of 13 grams of protein. The chicken is packed in water and seasoned with salt and chicken broth, so no dry, bland meat here. “It truly is ALL white meat,” mused one reviewer. “So many of the stores tout all white chicken, but when you open their cans, the contents leave a lot to be desired.” Fortunately, that’s not the case with this product.

Kirkland Signature Organic Pure Maple Syrup

If you know your maple syrups, you know that there’s a whole rating scale used to grade the color, richness, and taste of pure maple syrup. This one is grade A amber rich, so it’s not the strongest (which isn’t everyone’s cup of tea), but it’s not the lightest either. Pure maple syrup is always going to be pricier than other syrups next to the pancake mix at most supermarkets, but those aren’t actually maple—they’re made from corn syrup. A little goes a long way with this product, too. I like to drizzle this syrup over oatmeal, waffles, and French toast, and use it as a sweetener in sauces.

Kirkland Signature Creamy Almond Butter

Even if I have an unopened jar at home, I never leave Costco without picking up almond butter. Not only are the savings significant, I find that it has the best taste and texture for smoothies and oatmeal. I’ve tried other almond butter brands and keep coming back to this one. With just one ingredient—roasted almonds—I like that this nut butter doesn’t contain any added oils, salt, or sugar. And with more than 2,200 5-star reviews, it seems I’m not alone. “Best almond butter I’ve ever had,” wrote one Costco shopper.

Kirkland Signature Pecan Halves

Costco’s walnut halves are a best seller, but the pecan halves are popular too. These versatile and nutritious nuts have garnered thousands of positive reviews for the quality, taste, price, and convenience. Who has time to shell three pounds of pecans themselves? With only one ingredient—pecans—these are a blank canvas for snacking and both sweet and savory recipes. Many reviewers say they’re delicious on their own for a healthy snack, but they also freeze well. Others prefer to use them in baked goods, such as pecan pie and candied nuts.

Crunchmaster Multi-Grain Crackers

What’s vegan, kosher, gluten-free, and goes well with dip? These crackers. Gluten-free crackers in particular can be hard to find, but these have been well received by Costco shoppers. They’re made with grains and seeds for some added fiber, and they won’t crumble on you when you’re scooping up hummus or guacamole. “These are sturdy as heck, so [they are] excellent as a dipper,” shared one customer. But how do they taste? “Have not shared these with anyone who has not loved them,” another person noted.

Season Sardine Fillets In 100% Olive Oil

Tinned fish is having a moment because it’s a convenient source of protein and fatty acids, but it can be polarizing. These canned sardines are skinless, which customers confirm is true in the reviews. They’re also boneless—“there is not a single fishbone,” writes in one reviewer. What’s more, the sardines are packed in olive oil, providing even more omega-3s. Want to whip up something with these sardines? Some reviewers mention adding hot sauce and enjoying these healthy little fish straight from the tin. Others add them to noodle dishes, like ramen and pho.

Ocean Spray Craisins Whole Dried Cranberries

If you make a lot of yogurt bowls, oatmeal, salads, or trail mix, you’ll love these dried cranberries (aka craisins)—thousands of Costco customers sure do. The resealable bag weighs a whopping four pounds, which is sure to last a while as you experiment with them as a topping or in baked goods. You can pretty much use dried cranberries in any way you’d use raisins, though people tend to prefer the taste of these morsels.

General Mills Cheerios Cereal

You can buy Cheerios cereal at nearly every grocery store, but a warehouse will typically have the best price on this breakfast staple. Costco carries a 2-pack of large, 20-ounce boxes. Cheerios are perfect for busy mornings and big families, but they’re also one of the healthiest cereals you can buy, since they’re made with whole grain oats and provide 4 grams of fiber per serving. “The price is right and the quantity is huge,” noted one 5-star reviewer. Enjoy this cereal with a cup of milk for some protein, and add in some fresh fruit for a boost of fiber.