I have a miniature kitchen, so I’m always looking for ways to simplify my meals and prepare them more efficiently. Sheet pan recipes are one of my go-to dinners, especially on busy weeknights. Recently, however, I began to notice inconsistencies in the texture of my roasted vegetables and baked tofu — even when using the same recipe. I’d achieve crispy perfection some evenings, while other batches turned out soggy or underdone. 

A few months ago, I bought the oven thermometer that Ina Garten keeps in her personal kitchen, and my cooking woes disappeared almost immediately. Consistency is key when it comes to oven temperature, so snag Taylor’s large analog oven thermometer for just $5 at Amazon.

Taylor Large Analog Oven Thermometer

In a 2021 video with NYT cooking, Ina Garten shared the kitchen products she can’t live without. This large analog oven thermometer is one of her top picks. The beloved chef explained that she has “lots of oven thermometers because no matter what it says on the dial, the oven itself could be totally different.” As soon as I hung the gadget on my top oven rack, I understood how right she was.

According to the brand and thousands of shoppers, Taylor’s analog thermometer is always 100% accurate. It reads temperatures from 100°F  to 600°F, making it great for cooking and baking foods of all kinds. With more accurate temperature readings, I’ve been able to achieve chewy-yet-crispy chocolate chip cookies and crusty sourdough boules in my formerly unreliable oven. It’s also ideal for juicy, not dry, Thanksgiving turkey, per several Amazon shoppers.

It has over 6,300 five-star ratings on Amazon due to its no-frills reliability. “Buy it if you have any doubts about your oven. Or even if you don’t — it might surprise you,” advised one satisfied shopper. 

I appreciate the thermometer’s versatility. It has a flat base that is stable enough to stand up on your oven rack, or you can hang it using the built-in hook at the top. The 2.5-inch dial is small enough not to get in the way when you’re putting them in the oven but large enough to clearly display results.

Accuracy is a must no matter what you’re cooking, so grab the oven thermometer that Ina Garten and thousands of shoppers recommend for only $5.

More Oven Thermometers to Shop:

Pecula Analog Oven Thermometer

KitchenAId Analog Oven Thermometer

OXO Good Grips Oven Thermometer

Tescoma Gradius Oven Thermometer

Efeng Oven Thermometer

At the time of publishing, the price was $5.