Aquaphor’s balm is another product that garnered praise from multiple dermatologists, particularly for its excellent overall value. The drugstore pick is one of the most reliably hydrating, thanks to an ingredient list complete with skin nourishers including shea butter, vitamin E, and castor seed oil. “It’s highly occlusive, works well for very, very dry lips, and gives a glossy finish—all at an affordable price point,” says Dr. Castilla.

“I’ve been using this lip balm for as long as I can remember,” says Glamour contributor Brigitt Earley. “Sure, it’s a little bit greasy upon application, but it’s not at all sticky, and there’s really nothing that compares when it comes to hydration.”

Type: Chemical / SPF: 30 / Active ingredients: Avobenzone, octinoxate, octisalate, octocrylene, oxybenzone / Water-resistant: No / Applicator: Tube